GRANT
NUMBER:
NA46FD0045, NA57FD0082
NMFS
NUMBER:
92-SWR-058, 93-SWR-050
REPORT
TITLE:
Propagation of Reef Corals in International Aquarium Trade
AUTHOR:
Heslinga, Gerald A.; Micronesian Mariculture Demonstration
Center, Koror, Palau
PUBLISH
DATE:
January 15, 1995
AVAILABLE
FROM:
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Regional
Office, 501 West Ocean Boulevard, Suite 4200, Long Beach,
CA 90802-4018. PHONE: (562) 980-4033
ABSTRACT

There are a
number of uses for mariculture products. Traditionally
they were a source of food, and to a lesser extent, for
jewelry (pearls and trochus). However, niche industries
are developing, and the international aquarium trade has
proven to be a valuable outlet for maricultured giant
clams and tropical fish. This multimillion dollar
industry is currently constrained by two factors-the increasingly
restrictive regulatory climate surrounding the collection
of tropical specimens and the negative public perception
by individuals who are involved in unsustainable harvest
of desired species. This is especially true for those
species that are central to the marine ecosystem such
as giant clams, corals, and marine invertebrates. Today
the harvest of hard corals is totally or partially banned
in many nations and many species of corals are regulated
by the Convention on the International Trade in Endangered
Species (e.g., the family of Scleractinia and certain-Hydrozoan,
Anthecatans and Stolonifera). One response of the aquarium
industry has been to deemphasize the sale of wild caught
coral specimens and promote the production and sale of
artificial corals which are typically fabricated of molded
plastic. While a reasonable approach, this has left a
significant number of hobbyists seeking environmentally
friendly alternatives.
In 1992 the
MMDC received support for a project with the goal of developing
methods for the controlled, sustainable mass propagation
of commercially valuable corals for the international
salt water aquarium trade. The project was to focus on
three families (Alcyonacea, Scleractinea, and Zoanthidea)
of coral during a three award project, with the following
objectives for each family: locate and identify commercially
valuable species of each family, conduct experiments aimed
at developing cost-effective protocols for reproducing
two or three species of each family, test market in cooperation
with local and international wholesalers and report results
at trade shows and in technical articles.
The first award
focused on three of species soft coral (Alcyonacea) and
ran for 12 months in 1993 and 1994. Two species were successfully
propagated and marketed (Sarcophyton trocheliophorum and
Nepthea sp). An agreement was reached with a private aquarium
wholesaler and demand for the corals proved very strong,
selling for $4-$7 per specimen. A second award focusing
on the Scleractinids was awarded but was not implemented
due to personnel change at the MMDC. Despite the truncation
of the project it is rated as an administrative success.
Operationally the project was successful, and cancellation
of the second award appears not to have constrained the
development of this niche market. A number of other entities,
both in the private and public (UOG, the Honolulu Aquarium)
sector have continued experimenting and several are marketing
stony corals.
The project
cost a total of $84,799 (the second and third phase were
terminated by mutual consent). The markets grew considerably
despite cancellation of the second phase of the cultured
coral propagation project and at least three private firms
were active as of 1995. The NPV of the project is conservatively
estimated at $321,842 with a B/C of 1.67. This estimate
does not include other coral propagation activities in
the hard and carpet corals which were stimulated as a
result of the project. The cancellation of the second
and third phases of the project can also be viewed as
"savings" but has not been added to the benefit
portion of the NPV calculation. This is an example of
a Case II B/C in which the activity did not exist prior
to the project.