GRANT
NUMBER: NA77FD0070
NMFS NUMBER: 96-SER-029
REPORT
TITLE:
Application of Nutritional Strategies for the Development
of Low-Pollution Feeds for Marine Species
AUTHOR:
C. R. Arnold and D. Allen Davis
PUBLISH
DATE:
January
19, 1999
AVAILABLE
FROM:
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southeast Region, 9721
Executive Center Drive, St Petersburg, Florida 33702.
TELEPHONE: (813) 570-5324
ABSTRACT

This research
was designed to advance environmentally sound aquaculture
through the development and demonstration of low-pollution
feeds for the commercial production of red drum, Sciaenops
ocellatus and the Pacific white shrimp, Penaeus
vannamei. A portion of this research evaluated
the use of a feed grade protease (FGP) as a potential
dietary supplement to enhance protein retention in juvenile
shrimp and fish offered high quality practical diets.
The supplementation of 0.1 to 0.4 g FGP/100g diet did
not result in increases in weight gain or feed efficiency
for either species. Based on these results, as well as
other published studies, it would appear that enzyme treatments
of feeds and/or feed stuffs will be most beneficial in
poorly digested feeds and/or feed stuffs or in situations
in which there is no endogenous enzyme source. However
in diets designed to contain high digestible nutrients,
such as those used reduce pollution loading, enhancement
of nutrient availability appears minimal. The second component
of this research initiated nutrition studies for the development
of growout diets for red drum and also evaluated the potential
of phase feeding strategies. These studies represent the
first attempts to evaluate nutritional requirements of
large red drum under controlled conditions. The first
growth trial evaluated six practical diet formulations
that were offered to red drum (initial mean weight 50
g) over a 13-week growth trial. Results indicate that
reducing the protein content of the feed from 44 to 32%
will significantly reduce growth and feed efficiency values.
Increasing the lipid content, and subsequently the E:P
ratio, of the 44% protein diet from 6.8 to 13.2% did result
in some positive increases in performance (e.g. increased
FE as well as slight increases in protein conversion efficiency
and final weight). However, the negative aspects of increased
lipid deposition as demonstrated by significant increases
in intraperitoneal fat deposition may outweigh any increases
in performance. Additionally, reducing the E:P ration
of the 32% protein diet by replacing wheat starch with
indigestible filler, did not result in a significant increase
in consumption or final weights of the fish. This response
would indicate that the carbohydrate component of low
protein diets is probably not being digested and hence
is adding to the organic loading of a culture systems.
Another method to reduce production cost and nutrient
loading in growout systems would be to utilize phase feeding
strategies that would employ reduced level of protein
as the fish grows. To evaluate this feeding strategy three
practical diets were formulated to contain 44, 40 and
36% protein. Red drum (mean initial weight 70.8g) were
either feed these diets throughout a 17-week growth trial
or offered the 44% protein diet for the first 8-weeks
and then the 40 or 36% protein diets for the remainder
of the growth trial. Although, the differences in final
weights were not significant, there was a general decrease
(592.8 vs 543.3g) in weights of the fish as the protein
content of the diet was reduced from 44 to 36% respectively.
A similar response was also seen in the phase feeding
treatments. Similarly, significant reductions in FE values
were observed as protein content of the diet was reduced.
Given the minimal differences in the final weights of
the fish, reducing the protein content of growout diets
appears to be a potentially viable option. However, when
considering this each producer must consider his situation.
Particular consideration must be given to reductions in
FE, since this will result in increased cost associated
with shipping, feed milling and storage. Additionally,
as demonstrated in previous research reductions in the
nutrient density of the diet will also result in increased
organic loading of the culture system, which may lead
to increased costs for pollution abatement. These results,
will facilitate improvements in both growout diets and
feeding strategies for the commercial production of marine
species.